Collier, J.L. & Collier, C. (1974). My Brother Sam is Dead. New York: Scholastic, Inc. ISBN: 0439783607
· Plot Summary
"Life" Meeker and his son Tim are are loyal to the King of England during a time when American Colonial troops are struggling to gain independence from the monarchy. Tim's older brother, Sam, has chosen to side the Colonials against his parent's wishes. Putting his education at Yale, and his sweetheart (Betsy), and his family behind, Sam sets out to help the rebels. Things are not black and white in Redding, PA, however, and the town is composed of divided loyalties. Ultimately, Tim loses his father and brother to the injustices that occur during wartime, that sometimes have nothing to do with battle.
· Critical Evaluation
One of the best works of historical fiction to date, a truly riveting novel. The author's choice to have Life die on a British prison ship, and Sam killed when he is falsely accused of stealing his own family's cattle, is wrenching. It illustrates well how even the best individuals can become targets during war time, even at the hands of their own chosen side.
· Reader’s Annotation
Suitable for both genders, with strong characters portrayed from each. An informative piece of fiction, that includes a chapter on the real elements included in the story.
· Information about the author
James Lincoln is musician and editor, who in combination with his historian brother, Christopher, has written eight novels in this genre. The have also written more than two dozen non-fiction works for young adults. J.L. lives in New York City, while his brother lives in Connecticut.
· Genre
Historical Fiction
· Curriculum Ties
History
· Booktalking Ideas
Problem of choosing sides in the American Revolutionary War.
Morale and morality in war time.
· Reading Level/Interest Age
Grades 4-6/Ages 9-11
· Why did you include this book in the titles you selected?
I was assigned this book in the sixth grade, and managed to read half of it before the school realized I had been placed in the wrong class. The storyline interested me, and I did finish it, but hastily because of my other workload. This book is also considered a classic in the area of tween fiction, so I thought it was worth revisiting.
